🚨 Jill Zarin’s family is facing a truly creepy Hamptons mystery after Ally Shapiro claimed suspected squatters may have broken into their Sag Harbor home, slept in the beds, used the bathrooms, drank alcohol, and then vanished before anyone caught them!!! 😳🏠🔥

Ally Shapiro shared that the Sag Harbor Police Department came to investigate and asked neighbors for security camera footage

Jill Zarin’s daughter Ally Shapiro believes “squatters” broke into her family’s Hamptons home and left a disastrous mess inside.

On Tuesday, May 26, Shapiro, 33, took to TikTok to share that the family had received an unexpected phone call from their house manager that things at their Sag Harbor, N.Y., property “seemed weird.”

“Evidence: wine bottles, alcohol, martini shaker, toothbrushes and toothpaste in all the bathrooms and a child’s toothbrush in mine, the washing machines were definitely used, my mom’s bed was definitely slept in,” the creator claims.

She went on to explain that the Sag Harbor Police Department was called and responded to investigate. According to Shapiro, police came by and asked neighbors for security camera footage.

“We’re getting a Ring camera and footage from the neighbors, so if it was you, we’re coming for you,” Shapiro warns. In the video, the Real Housewives of New York alum’s boyfriend Gary Brody offered another playful warning for the possible intruders: “If it was you, don’t come back and remember after midnight it’s a haunted house. If you come in here, it’s dangerous.”

In the comments, one user asked why the family’s property lacked their own security cameras in the first place. “There are cameras, they were found unplugged. I don’t know if they unplugged them,” Shapiro claims in a follow-up video posted on May 27. “My gut feeling is that it’s someone close to us.” She adds: “Whether it’s a neighbor or someone we know, I don’t know. It’s really weird that someone broke in and didn’t steal anything and slept in our beds.”

Shapiro also has reason to believe the potential intrusion happened pretty recently.

“The toothbrushes were wet. The sink was wet,” she alleges. “So they had just been there, it’s not like they were there a while ago and had left. They probably were there, planning on coming back, and then were surprised by the house manager being home.”

She adds: “It’s a huge invasion of privacy, it’s very honestly unsettling, scary whatever… It’s not funny at all.”

PEOPLE has reached out to the Sag Harbor Police Department for comment.